When patients improve after treatment, the therapy itself is only part of the reason. Factors such as trust between patient and clinician, communication style, treatment expectations, and even the care environment can influence recovery.
A study published in Scientific Reports by researchers in the Duke Department of Orthopaedic Surgery provides the first expert-guided framework for measuring these often-overlooked influences, known as contextual factors.
An international panel of experts evaluated 227 instruments used to assess factors that can shape therapeutic encounters and clinical outcomes. After reviewing the scientific quality and practical usefulness of each measure, the team identified 20 instruments for inclusion in a clinical toolkit designed to help researchers assess contextual factors more consistently.
"For years the vital elements of human care, like noise, light, space, proximity and even the fundamental mood, tone and alliance between patient and clinician have been relegated to the background to be filtered out,” said lead author Jennifer A. Bent, PT of Duke University Health System. "The contextual forces toolkit" now gives both clinicians and researchers badly needed tools to help quantify what is going on during the treatment session and help make the invisible drivers of recovery visible and actionable.”
The review also revealed major gaps.
While existing instruments can effectively measure relatively stable characteristics, such as patient beliefs or clinician traits, the researchers found few validated ways to capture what happens during care itself. These harder-to-measure factors include a clinician's emotional state, nonverbal communication, therapeutic touch and other real-time interactions that may influence recovery. The findings suggest that some of the most important influences on healing remain difficult to study.
"Identifying what we cannot yet measure is just as important as cataloging what we can," said senior co-author Chad E. Cook, PT, PhD , professor in orthopaedic surgery.
The study provides a roadmap for future research aimed at better understanding how the clinical experience itself contributes to patient outcomes, to ultimately improve patient care.
The study was funded by the National Institutes of Health and grew out of collaborations fostered through ForceNet, an interdisciplinary research consortium focused on connecting force-based mechanistic research with patient outcomes.